The Girl Scouts of the USA (GSUSA) has recently faced scrutiny over issues related to gender inclusivity and its evolving stance on faith, prompting renewed interest in faith-based alternatives like American Heritage Girls (AHG). A recent online form regarding sleepaway camp, which reportedly asked parents about their children's preferred pronouns and gender-inclusive sleeping arrangements, sparked debate and discussion. This incident follows previous controversies, including the organization's 1993 decision to make the word "God" optional in its oath.
Patti Garibay, founder and national executive director of American Heritage Girls, voiced her concerns about the GSUSA's direction, stating that it has "entangled itself in the ever-shifting winds of today's culture." Garibay, who spent over a decade with the Girl Scouts before founding AHG in 1995, expressed her disappointment with the organization's departure from its traditional values. She questioned the current identity of the GSUSA, asking, "Is today's GSUSA the Girl Scouts or Boy Scouts — or something in between?" and noted the sadness of many alumnae who feel the organization has "lost its way."
Garibay's decision to create AHG stemmed from her belief that the Girl Scouts had drifted from their original mission. The 1993 vote to make "God" optional in the Girl Scout oath was a pivotal moment for her, prompting her departure and the subsequent formation of AHG as a Christian alternative. Garibay explained, "This wasn't a light decision… to just start an alternative… because I'm not liking what's going on." She envisioned AHG as a space where Christian values and family involvement would be central to the girls' experience.
Today, AHG boasts over 60,000 members, making it the largest faith-based scouting organization globally. The group emphasizes a "deeper walk with Christ" and provides resources for parents navigating contemporary social and cultural challenges through its "Raising Godly Girls" platform. AHG's website highlights the importance of a faith-based worldview, stating that it shapes a girl's understanding of herself, her purpose, and her ability to impact the world.
In response to the recent controversy, the GSUSA affirmed its commitment to inclusivity, stating, "We’re proud that Girl Scouts of the USA (GSUSA) is an inclusive organization that uplifts all girls." They emphasized creating a safe and supportive environment for all members and highlighted their practice of working with local councils to accommodate transgender youth. The GSUSA website clarifies its policy, stating that if a child is recognized and lives culturally as a girl, they are welcome to participate.
The GSUSA reiterates its mission to build courage, confidence, and character in girls, empowering them to make a positive impact on the world. They highlight the various enriching experiences offered, such as field trips, skill-building activities, community service, and cultural exchanges.
